Debian's graphical installer - what's the point?

Remember when people would say - oh, Debian is hard to install…? I remember when their installer routine went ‘graphical’ which really meant mouse support and softer lines, rounder edges to stuff. Graphical was the answer to hard.

Over the releases I have used the graphical installer a couple times, saw little changes. I might have a disease where easy stuff is too hard for me. Heh, but, I don’t think the graphical installer is any ‘easier’. I think it’s one of those things that someone saw the need for, but, it’s just a ‘layer’ fix - I dunno - to a simpleton like me the regular (expert) installation routine makes it easier to see and understand what’s happening. It’s faster and it works great; it wasn’t broken then, either.

This is on my mind because I reinstalled last week and I used the graphical installer and I messed up somehow and had to fix, and what was broke wasn’t getting fixed, so, reinstall.

Maybe I am one of those people that, even though I live to share and collaborate, I DO think that you need to earn the Linux. Not because - hey, lookit us, the cool kids - no, but, because I believe that anyone using anything should understand how it works, at least a little, and not just flip some switch to on when using or employing something unfamiliar. Not only is it an immense failure of expectations, that’s when all the whining starts, and the blaming - notice, lack of personal responsibility.

Before I turn this into a 9 page diatribe, I’m just saying - well, you already read what I am saying. Teach to fish don’t just give a fish? Lay that groundwork, have that expectation? I dunno…

old man yells at clouds…and I’m not even old, yet.

4 Likes

Every time I try to use the graphical installer it’s broke. I normally just use the non graphical one to get it done.

3 Likes

You’re right on with this statement!

I don’t think that EVERYONE should have to know and understand a tool really well in order to use it, as long as they do understand what the tool does, how to operate it and how to be safe with it.

For example, if you use a saw, you should know how to saw back and forth, how to cut with it, what kinds of materials the size and type of saw can cut, how to prevent YOURSELF from getting cut, and so forth.

I believe a similar analogy goes with the computer. If you are just using it to read Email and browse, you don’t have to understand how to compile and build a kernel - besides, even here, I wonder how many people can do that! But it IS necessary to understand how to properly start it up and how to properly shut it down, and it’s important to know what you’re running and how to activate, start, deactivate and stop whatever you’re using.

5 Likes

To use an analogy, you would (hopefully) never venture into an unknown neighbourhood without first getting “the lay of the land”, in the way of knowing

  • how safe is it,
  • what do I use to get there,
  • how am I getting there,
  • how do I recognize what I am looking for when I see it,
  • how do I bring back what I went to get,
  • how to do all that in a way that I can do it again … without breaking anything,
  • etc …

Just basic common sense, instead of walking around like “air heads”, oblivious to all around you!

4 Likes

We are having this discussion in the context of those who are using the computer (desktop, tablet, laptop, smartphone) primarily for the purpose of communicating. A large percentage of people really have no idea how any of this works. Some of them at least know how to turn their devices on, do what they want, and then do something else. For them, that’s fine. Maybe some of us here don’t program, but most of us do know how to get around.

I have a degree in this stuff, and I’m retired now, and plenty of new things appear. The difference for me, and others who have that educational and/or professional experience, we either know what to do or we can figure it out when a new or different tool becomes available.

The other type of user simply does not have the background, skill, or interest to figure out new stuff, though the inquisitive individuals really can figure it out, regardless if they have the background or not.

Thoughts on this?

3 Likes

Of course they don’t, if I had a penny for every 10th time I’ve heard “it works in Windows” Donald Trump would appear to be broke next to me. Because of Windows nobody had to learn how things work.
It makes me kind of sad that Linux has been “dumbed down” so it can be more widely accepted by users that don’t care to lean how things work.

4 Likes

Oh, don’t even get me started.

One time, after we had already agreed on laces (because OMFG, D’uh!) my then-wife produced shoes with velcro closures for our son to learn to ‘tie his shoes’ on. Pfft - Hell, no. She then proceeded to argue their effectiveness…wha…WTF!? She argued with me vehemently that velcro was better, for whatever stupid reason she leaned-on, I don’t remember becuase I was dumbfounded. Course I hucked those shoes right into the trash and produced shoes w/laces we already had.

dexterity, patience, planning, theory, failure - you learn so much with laces…

I am still salty about that and her attitude > 20 years later because that’s how you raise, well…

I would also like to say contrary to tmick and I believe because of Windows - learning about how that box worked should have been enforced, what a mess. Remember when Microsoft had enough of the mad-clickers on their home windows boxes causing a ruckus with viruses and whatnot and then decided - we will just take over the machines and the surely did.

I am one of those super nerds that wants to grok everything and I approach everything with discovery first - so, I am probably not the best person to speak on this apathy stuff. THat’s one of those things that I don’t tolerate. Kills me as a human, though, a member of a species; wrecks me how we fight so hard to be wrong, and then, we double-down, you know, because agency. Like when that $PERSON flips you off after cutting you off…

laaaaaaaaaaaaaaand sakes!

Miguel dumbed the Linux down with Gnome3, and then he went to work for microsoft, didnt he?

4 Likes

Yeah, something like that!

I here you! Despite the fact that I REALLY like the Gtk+ toolkit, in terms of graphical capabilities, I have NEVER EVER had a fondness for GNOME. When it FIRST came out, I thought I’d like it, but when I found that there was little to zero configurability, I said, “Bye, bye!” But when the Xfce project went from the use of Xforms to Gtk+, I DID like that! Why, you may ask?

Simple; the Xfce methodology allowed me to customize just about everything with text readable, alterable configuration files!

The early KDE had a so-so license, and that’s why other desktops appeared but it had something that the others did not have - you may have guessed - YES - configurable text editable files!

When the Plasma project started, that pretty much took me out of KDE, except to occasionally EXPLORE it. They’ve tamed it over the years and brought back more editable components, but it’s WAY heavier than anything I need. At least it has SOME flexibility.

Readers who have been around for a few weeks or months know that I like text editors and customizable interfaces. I don’t have anywhere near as many things that I want to customize as our friend @machiner, but we at least share a common interest of wanting complete control over what we use.

Since all I absolutely “need” (that’s if using a computer is truly a need, not just a “desire” or a “geek’s drug”) is a Web browser, then I use an editor to be able to write and modify text, and occasionally fairly short, simple scripts and tools, and because of this, a desktop environment is gross overkill for me.

So what’s the simplest interface for me? I pick IceWM as the Window Manager (WM), not because it’s the #1 leanest; these days it’s not the leanest, it just has the most basic config language syntax. Some of the others are text editable, but they insist on using some variation of XML, which I feel on the “simple level” is still overkill;why do that when you just want to specify a FEW things without having to possess a graduate degree in the variations of XML, HTML5+ or whatever? Yes, I can read up and figure out how to use them, but JWM is a great example - it’s an excellent, easy to use, very efficient Window Manager, but it has display elements that are NOT easy to remember unless you work with them constantly; otherwise JWM would be my favorite. WM 2 would be Fluxbox; it has the simple syntax like IceWM, but unless you rewire the keys, requires the use of double buttons or a middle mouse button - why? Openbox is pretty easy, but like the others the syntax for the config file isn’t as simple as the interface for IceWM.

I decided this twenty or more years ago and between 20-30 years back, IceWM also happened to be among the leanest WM; it remains lean today, but a few extra “features” have crept in. Fortunately feature creep has been moderate so I’ve been able to “stick with it”.

So here’s the thing: if you want every trick in the book and you LOVE eye candy, then you probably crave KDE Plasma; it can do just about everything.

That is 100% okay; that’s WHY we have all of these choices. @machiner has what he prefers, and it’s quite interesting what he’s able to do with his stuff, which he’s built up over decades of use and experience.

I also have those decades, but I’ve CUT DOWN my interface because I only NEED a fraction of what I once needed, so I’ve cleaned out a few things. If I get tired of trying out twenty or more different text editors and Web browsers I’ll probably pare down even more stuff; in the meantime, I use a collection of very short alias commands, with many one character aliases to give my lousy typing hands a chance to do what I want without typing out stuff like sudo apt-get update; sudo apt-get upgrade; doom sync; doom upgrade; restartEmacs, and then later killall emacs! Instead I type u;d;re to update my system and start or restart Emacs; when I’m ALL DONE with Emacs I can type ke and the “time efficient” Emacs daemon that I start to make getting in and out of Emacs quick is also something I can ELIMINATE when I’m not planning on using Emacs for a while, or “done for today”.

Well, I CAN type, but NOT all the time; that’s my discourse for today! MY points are all over the place, aren’t they?

3 Likes

You know, I used to run KDE, back in the day, v1.x, I think. I loved it - ugly as hell and beautiful at the same time, limited, but, pretty cohesive; and, as you write, you could just open a config file and break it! Also, I think, I was confronted with not having to confirm a choice, in KDE for the first time. Windows made me confirm stuff all the time and I hated that - pfft, I just commanded it, make it so - don’t second guess me, machine…heh. In the Linux, you make choices real-time.

One time I compiled gnome. Oy, took 2 days!

5 Likes